The arbitration in Espíritu Santo Holdings, LP and L1bre Holding, LLC v. United Mexican States concerned a digital taximeter project in Mexico City and claims exceeding USD 2.1 billion.[1] On 26 March 2026, the tribunal reportedly dismissed all claims in favour of Mexico.[2] The case arose from an investment in Servicios Digitales Lusad, S. de […]
Timing of Jurisdictional Objections in Arbitration
Arbitration rewards procedural vigilance. A party that believes a tribunal lacks jurisdiction usually cannot stay silent, contest the merits, and only later invoke the objection if the case turns unfavourable. Typical jurisdictional objections that may be raised in arbitration include: No valid arbitration agreement; A party is not bound by the arbitration agreement; The tribunal […]
Devas v. Antrix: Dutch Enforcement and the Limits of Seat-Based Annulment
With the Dutch Supreme Court’s 6 March 2026 dismissal of Antrix’s cassation challenge, attention has once again turned to one of the most closely watched India-linked arbitration disputes in recent years. The dismissal leaves in place the Hague Court of Appeal’s 17 December 2024 judgment in Devas Multimedia America Inc. v. Antrix Corporation Ltd., permitting […]
What Options Remain for Investor-State Arbitration Under the ECT?
This note deals with the current legal framework of investor-State arbitration under the Energy Charter Treaty (the “ECT”). The landscape of the application of the ECT has become blurry after several major developments in recent years: withdrawals, modernisation of the ECT, not to mention the impact of the Komstroy decision,[1] which has by no means […]
London Commercial Court: ICSID Awards Are Not Assignable (Operafund v Spain)
In Operafund Eco-Invest SICAV Plc and Schwab Holding AG v Kingdom of Spain [2025] EWHC 2874 (Comm), the English Commercial Court held that awards rendered under the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States (“ICSID Convention”) or the Energy Charter Treaty 1994 (“ECT”) are not assignable to third […]